alex.m.thompson
  • Home
  • Biography
  • Publications
  • Photos
  • Research
  • Collaborators
  • Blog

my thoughts on science

Chemical conundrum 

10/17/2015

0 Comments

 
​This is going to be a drastic departure from the topics that I normally blog about. However, I hope it is still interesting to people who regularly read my ramblings about evolution and animal behaviour.
 
The reason for this post is that it’s a topic I’ve been working on at work and some of the things that I have found have shocked me slightly. The topic is chemical regulation, something that has never interested me before but has a big impact on our day to day lives. This is a brief commentary on its speed and what rules are used to govern it,
 
Firstly, a good place to start with chemicals is to understand that, for most, the dose makes the poison. So for most chemicals if you receive a low dose then you’ll suffer no ill effects. But sometimes things like timing of exposure have a big impact on humans, e.g. thalidomide, or the dose may be fine for us but not so fine for wildlife.
 
Secondly, there are two ways of assessing if a chemical is going to be bad for us: hazard based assessment or risk based assessment. In a nutshell, hazard based roughly says that if any chemical is bad then it should be banned, whereas risk based looks at likelihood and level of exposure as well. Risk based is probably better but only if you have good data on exposure likelihoods and levels, otherwise it’s just guesswork. This article briefly goes over the debate in Europe about which system to use: LINK. Out of this type of debate the Precautionary Principle has arisen, basically safety first, but a lot of people say that this is unscientific because it doesn’t take risk into account.
 
So why am I writing about this? Well as a scientist I think that risk based is probably the most sensible but after looking into two chemicals Tributylin (TBT) and Diethylstilbestrol (DES) I am not so sure anymore.
 
The case of TBT:
This chemical was used as an antifouling agent on boat, to stop barnacles etc growing on the hulls of ships and other aquatic craft. It did a great job, but one problem: it inhibits the Cytochrome P450, which is involved in converting androgens to oestrogen. This caused huge number of female molluscs to be unable to get rid of their testosterone and basically grown male(ish) genitalia, something called imposex. This had a huge impact on benthic organisms and impacted on algal growth and young fish too. This was discovered in the 1980s and in some countries it was banned by 1987, but even in those it still has knock on effects to this day. But it took until 2003 for the the International Maritime Organisation to finally officially phase it out.
 
The case of DES:
DES was used as a preventative treatment to stop women having miscarriages and its use started in 1938. However, by the 1953 it had been shown not to help with miscarriage prevention at all. Some not very nice trends started to be noticed by doctors and then Chicago’s Arthur Herbst showed that daughters of mothers who had used DES had a much higher incidence of rare vaginal cancers at early ages. It turns out that from long-term studies that women prescribed DES have higher risk of breast cancer and in addition to cervical cancer daughters are more likely to have reproductive tract problems and difficulties with pregnancy. This drug was also prescribed to girls who were too tall, to stop them growing. It took until 1971 for it to be banned in the US and 1978 for Europe.
 
It took a staggeringly long time for both of these chemicals to be banned for those uses, TBT worst of all because its effects were known in the 80s and it took till the early 2000s to be fully banned.
 
These two examples show how long it can take to show that something is unsafe and should be banned. I’m not advocating for everything that may be hazardous to be banned straight away, but the argument against using the Precautionary Principle is not as simple as Science v Non-science. We must learn from examples like these but do so by developing better and early tests for risk.
0 Comments

    Author

    I am a behavioural ecologist, my main interests revolve around familial conflicts and their resolutions. However, my scientific interests are fairly broad.

    View my profile on LinkedIn

    Archives

    October 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    December 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012

    Categories

    All
    90
    99 Percent Invisible
    99pi
    Africa
    Alien Species
    Allee Effect
    Altruism
    Amazon
    Andreas Wagner
    Anthropocene
    Apostle Bird
    Arabian Babbler
    Attenborough
    Babbler
    Badger Cull
    Badgers
    Banded Mongoose
    BBC
    Bee
    Big Bang Fair
    Bighorn Sheep
    Biodiversity
    Biological Control
    Biology
    Biology Letters
    Bird For Britain
    Birds
    Birthday
    Black Sparrowhawk
    Blogs
    Book
    Book Review
    Breeding
    Brood Parasitism
    Brown Tree Snake
    Burying Beetles
    Butterflies
    Butyric Acid
    Camel
    Cane Toad
    Chemicals
    Chernobyl
    Chimp
    Chronotype
    CITES
    Climate Change
    Cod
    Collaborations
    Color
    Colour
    Colour Vision
    Common Misunderstandings
    Communication
    Competition
    Conference
    Conflict
    Conservation
    Conservatism
    Conservative
    Cool Papers
    Cool Research
    Cooperation
    Crime
    Crows
    Cuckoo
    Dad Media
    Dailymail
    Dalai Lama
    Darting
    Darwin
    Darwin's Finches
    Deception
    Deception Africa
    Decision Making
    Deer
    DES
    Dieter Lukas
    Disney
    Diving
    Documentary
    Dominance
    Drongo
    Eavesdropping
    Economics
    Education
    Elephants
    Epigenetics
    EU
    Evil
    Evolution
    Evolutionary Approach
    Extracurricular
    Fear
    Fennec Fox
    Filming
    Fish
    Fittness
    Fitz
    Football
    Foraging
    Fork Tailed Drongo
    Fork-tailed Drongo
    Free Radicals
    Future
    Gastranaut
    Good Genes
    Ground Squirrel
    Group Living
    Grouse
    Guardian
    Hands
    Hedgehog
    Hero
    Home Advantage
    Honeyguide
    Hornbill
    Hot Birds
    Human
    Human Impact
    Human-wildlife Conflict
    Hummingbirds
    Inbreeding
    Intelligent Bird
    Interesting Research
    Intrasexual
    Invasive Species
    Isbe 2014
    Ivory
    Kalahari
    Kardashian
    Kenya
    Kids
    K-index
    Koala
    Language
    Larks
    Learning
    Long-term
    Male-male Competition
    Male Tenure
    Mantis
    Mating
    Meerkat
    Meta-analysis
    Mice
    Misconceptions
    Miya Warrington
    Mongoose
    Moths
    Mysogyny
    Natural Selection
    Nepotism
    Nestling Growth
    New Papers
    New Research
    Niche
    NO2
    Nuclear
    Old Boys Club
    Olfaction
    Ornithology
    Overfishing
    Owls
    Oxidative Stress
    Parental Care
    Peer Review
    Percy FitzPatrick Institute
    Pest Control
    Pesticides
    Phd
    Phd Comics
    Phenotypic Plasticity
    Pheromones
    Pied Babbler
    Pied Babblers
    Pied Crows
    PLoS One
    Poaching
    Podcasts
    Politcians
    Political Views
    Polymorphism
    Poor Reporting
    Population Change
    Population Decline
    Population Dynamics
    Precautionary Principle
    Public Understanding
    Raccoon
    Radiolab
    Raihani
    Random
    Raptors
    Reciprocity
    Red Deer
    Referendum
    Regulation
    Research
    Resource Dispersion Hypothesis
    Robin
    Rum
    Running
    Schools
    Science
    Science Education
    Science In The News
    Scientific Method
    Scimitarbill
    Scotland
    Seagull
    Sexism
    Sexual Conflict
    Sexual Selection
    Shrikes
    Signalling
    Singing
    Smell
    Sociality
    South Africa
    Speach
    Spring
    Stealing
    STEM
    STEMtech
    Stuff You Missed In History Class
    Stuff You Should Know
    Suppression
    Syntax
    SYSK
    Tamarisk
    TBT
    Teaching
    Temperature
    Theft
    Theory Of Mind
    The Telegraph
    The Times
    Tigers
    Tim Peake
    Top 10
    Tories
    Trees
    Uganda
    UK
    Urban
    Urban Animals
    Urbanisation
    Weaver
    Wheel
    Wild
    Winning
    Wood Wide Web
    World Cup
    World's Sneakiest Animals
    Wrinkle
    Youtube Channels
    Zebra Mussel

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.